+86-0510-85599233

NEWS

Clean air, a human right

Home / News Center / Industry News / What is the difference between PA/PE and PA/EVOH/PE forming films?

What is the difference between PA/PE and PA/EVOH/PE forming films?

Technical Fundamentals of Coextruded Forming Films

In the field of industrial vacuum packaging and thermoforming, the choice of material layers dictates the shelf life, structural integrity, and safety of the contained product. Forming films are typically multi-layer structures produced via co-extrusion, where different polymers are combined to leverage their unique physical properties. The most common configurations involve Polyamide (PA) and Polyethylene (PE), but for advanced applications, Ethylene Vinyl Alcohol (EVOH) is introduced to create a high-performance barrier.

The primary objective of these films is to undergo heat-induced shaping—thermoforming—where the film is drawn into a mold to create a cavity. This process requires a delicate balance of mechanical strength, puncture resistance, and gas permeability control. While standard PA/PE structures serve many general purposes, the transition to 9 Layer EVOH High Barrier Forming Film represents a significant leap in preservation technology for oxygen-sensitive commodities.

Composition and Material Characteristics of PA/PE Films

PA/PE forming films are the workhorses of the flexible packaging industry. These films utilize Polyamide (Nylon) for its structural properties and Polyethylene for its sealing capabilities.

The Role of Polyamide (PA)

PA acts as the "skeleton" of the film. It provides excellent thermoforming properties, allowing the film to stretch uniformly without thinning excessively at the corners of the mold. It also contributes significant abrasion resistance and high-temperature stability, which is critical during the heat-sealing phase of the packaging cycle.

The Role of Polyethylene (PE)

PE is the innermost layer that comes into direct contact with the product. Its primary function is to provide a reliable moisture barrier and a wide heat-sealing window. PE ensures that the package remains airtight and leak-proof, even if the sealing surfaces are contaminated with fats or liquids during the filling process.

Understanding the EVOH Advantage in 9 Layer Systems

The introduction of EVOH into the co-extrusion process transforms a standard film into a high-barrier solution. EVOH is widely recognized as one of the most effective thermoplastic materials for blocking gases.

In a 9-layer structure, the EVOH is typically "sandwiched" between layers of PA and tie resins. This positioning is strategic. Because EVOH is sensitive to moisture, surrounding it with hydrophobic layers ensures that its oxygen transmission rate (OTR) remains consistently low throughout the product's lifecycle. A 9-layer configuration allows for thinner individual layers with higher precision, resulting in a film that is more flexible yet more protective than traditional 3 or 5-layer alternatives.

Comparative Analysis: PA/PE vs. PA/EVOH/PE

The choice between these two film types often depends on the required shelf life and the sensitivity of the product to oxidation. Below is a breakdown of the functional differences.

Feature PA/PE Forming Film PA/EVOH/PE (9 Layer)
Oxygen Barrier Moderate (PA based) Superior (EVOH based)
OTR (cc/m2·24h) Typically 25 - 40 Less than 1.0
Aroma Retention Good Excellent
Puncture Resistance High Highest (9-layer symmetry)
Typical Application Frozen foods, Short-term dairy Fresh meat, MAP, Long-life medical

As demonstrated, the OTR of EVOH-based films is significantly lower, which is the deciding factor for products that undergo color changes or flavor degradation when exposed to oxygen.

Technical Performance of 9 Layer Co-extrusion

Modern extrusion technology allows for the distribution of polymers across 9 distinct layers. This complexity is not for aesthetic purposes but for functional optimization. By splitting the material into more layers, manufacturers can achieve several technical milestones:

  • Symmetric Structure: Reduces film curling, which improves the efficiency of high-speed thermoforming machines.
  • Enhanced Gloss and Clarity: Multiple layers of PA and specialized resins contribute to a high-transparency finish, essential for retail presentation.
  • Optimized Draw Ratio: The film can be stretched deeper (deep-draw) without structural failure, making it suitable for bulky industrial parts or large meat cuts.

Industrial and Commercial Application Scenarios

B2B buyers must match the film technology to the specific environmental stresses the package will face during logistics and storage.

Processed and Fresh Meat Packaging

Fresh proteins are highly susceptible to aerobic bacteria. PA/EVOH/PE films facilitate Modified Atmosphere Packaging (MAP), where a specific gas mix (typically CO2 and Nitrogen) is injected to replace oxygen. Without the EVOH barrier, these gases would escape, and oxygen would permeate back into the package, leading to rapid spoilage and a loss of "bloom" (the red color in beef).

Medical Device Sterilization

In medical applications, the forming film must maintain sterility for years. The multi-layer PA construction ensures that the package can withstand the rigors of Gamma radiation or ETO sterilization without becoming brittle or losing its hermetic seal. The high barrier properties prevent the ingress of any contaminants or humidity that could compromise sensitive diagnostic tools.

Operational Efficiency and Machine Compatibility

From a production standpoint, the physical behavior of the film on the thermoforming line determines the overall cost of operation. Standard PA/PE films are robust but may require higher heating temperatures. In contrast, advanced 9-layer films are engineered with specific resins that allow for lower forming temperatures, which reduces energy consumption and minimizes the risk of burning thin-walled areas of the package.

Key operational metrics include:

  • Yield: Thinner 9-layer films can offer the same protection as thicker 5-layer films, increasing the number of meters per roll.
  • Waste Reduction: Consistent thickness control across the web reduces the number of rejected packages due to leakers or thinning.
  • Sealing Integrity: Advanced PE blends in the sealant layer allow for faster line speeds as they reach fusion temperature more quickly.

Summary of Selection Criteria for Procurement

When deciding between PA/PE and PA/EVOH/PE, procurement departments should evaluate the following factors:

  1. Storage Temperature: Is the product frozen (PA/PE usually sufficient) or chilled (EVOH recommended)?
  2. Desired Shelf Life: Is the goal 30 days or 180 days? High OTR requirements demand EVOH.
  3. Forming Depth: Deep cavities (over 50mm) benefit from the uniform draw characteristics of 9-layer co-extrusion.
  4. Logistical Stress: Products with sharp edges or heavy weights require the superior puncture resistance found in multi-layered Nylon structures.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q1: Why is EVOH placed in the middle of a 9-layer film?

EVOH is sensitive to moisture, which can degrade its gas barrier properties. Placing it between PA and PE layers protects it from environmental humidity and internal product moisture, ensuring its effectiveness.

Q2: Can PA/PE films be used for vacuum packaging?

Yes, they are commonly used for vacuum packaging. However, they provide a lower gas barrier compared to EVOH-integrated films, making them better suited for products that do not require an extreme shelf life.

Q3: How does a 9-layer film help with "leakers" in production?

The multi-layer structure allows for more precise material distribution. This prevents weak spots during the thermoforming stretch, which is the primary cause of pinholes and "leakers" in the final package.

Q4: Is the transparency of EVOH films comparable to standard Nylon films?

Yes, high-quality 9-layer co-extruded films offer exceptional clarity and gloss, often exceeding the visual appeal of traditional structures due to better layer refinement.